When One Partner Wants Pets and The Other Doesn't

May 07, 2017 0 Comments A+ a-


Here are some issues to consider before deciding.
 
 
photo by Sharon Terry
Source: photo by Sharon Terry
 
My brother-in-law once said, “My wife’s priorities are: 1. The dog, 2. The kids, 3. Me.” Their handsome long-haired dog was fed prime cuts of meat, brushed and hugged frequently, and taken for long walks daily. My brother-in-law was feeling pangs of jealousy.
We all know (or even have in our homes) pets that receive lavish attention from at least one owner. What you may not see is the apprehension or resentment of the other adult in the home. It’s not that the other adult dislikes animals nor would they ever be unkind to an animal. Who does not instinctively understand the joy and comfort that a pet can bring to a home? Pets are invaluable for their companionship. Many studies have shown that animals relieve stress and anxiety for people of all ages. Some serve a function as watch-dogs, warning home-owners of strangers or other animals on the property. Barking dogs have provided warnings of fire and other life-threatening hazards. Let’s not forget the reliable service dogs, such as personal guide dogs for the vision-impaired, and the trusty canine companions for those with physical disabilities. This blog is in no way intended to question the value of pets in our homes.  However, it is not unusual for couples to disagree on the decision of whether or not to bring a pet into their home.

It helps to be mindful of all of the considerations in owning a pet. First, there is the problem of pet allergies. One or more people in the home may be allergic to the pet. According to the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America, 15 to 30% of people with allergies have an allergy to dogs, cats, or other animals. In the United States, 10 million people are allergic to cats (http://www.aafa.org/page/pet-dog-cat-allergies.aspx).  Symptoms may include itching or swelling of the eyes or nose, and stuffy nose. More extreme cases may involve coughing, wheezing, and shortness of breath. Sometimes rashes develop on the face, neck, or upper chest. In the most extreme cases, cat allergies may cause severe asthma attacks.
Secondly, consider the monetary costs of owning a pet, particularly costs related to dog ownership. These include: food, veterinary care, boarding, beds, treats, grooming, medications, dietary supplements, leashes, and toys.  Factor into the costs the reality that multiple-pet ownership is at an all-time high, with 44% of pet-owning households having more than one pet at a time (http://media.americanpetproducts.org/press.php?include=144262). Pet costs can mount up quickly. If one partner is willing to sacrifice other things to pay these costs but the other is not, conflict and unhappiness can result.

photo by Lauren Grande
Source: photo by Lauren Grande
 
 
Lastly, there are the more unusual, but still possible safety issues: dogs that bite mail carriers, and cats that scratch the neighbor’s children (yes, guilty as charged on that one).  I recall a past colleague who kept a pet cobra in his home until his wife announced that either it moves out or she would. Can you blame her?

Here are some recommendations about issues to discuss before making this type of decision.

1. Be aware of any medical issues, such as allergies, and make accommodations as needed. For some good examples of how to manage allergies, see the website for the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America, referenced above.

2. Consider the costs associated with pet ownership and include these costs in your budget if they are a concern for either of you. Estimates of some of the costs can be found online from companies such as American Pet Products.

3. Agree to some possible ground rules regarding the practical care of the pets. Who will take care of feeding, scooping poop, or litter box clean-up? Will the pets be allowed on the furniture and where will they sleep? Having some acceptable agreements in advance will minimize arguments later.

4. Listen to any other concerns your partner may have and address them as well as possible.
Being considerate of each other will increase the chances of making your home a peaceful and comforting place, regardless of what you decide to do.


photo by Lance Grande
Source: photo by Lance Grande